In a famous Supreme Court case in 1919 (Schneck v. United States), Justice Oliver Wendall Holmes, Jr. said that “the most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a crowded theater and causing panic.” He went on to point out that such an action would endanger others and therefore to limit free speech would be appropriate.

Today, in California, we are facing a situation where the freedom of parents to choose not to immunize their children with the MMR (measles, mumps, rubella) vaccine puts the children of other parents at risk of serious illness including high fever, runny nose, pneumonia, swelling of the brain and in 2 of every 1,000 cases, death. Statewide, there are 91 cases of measles in 2015, with two confirmed cases in Marin County. Some parents, relying upon research of the 1990’s alleging a connection between the MMR vaccine and autism, have chosen not to protect their children through immunization. (It should be noted that the research has been discredited by the scientific community.)

While parents may have the statutory right of refusal, they do not have the ethical right to expose others to their children’s lack of protection. In other words, having the right to do something does not mean it is always the right thing to do. Fifty years ago, children suffered from measles, mumps, pertussis (whooping cough), smallpox, chickenpox, polio, typhoid, diphtheria, tuberculosis, scarlet fever and tetanus, to name a few childhood diseases. Today, most of these diseases have been virtually eliminated, due to the development of vaccines. Would any of us as parents or grandparents want to return to the “good old days?” Would any of us want to be responsible for the illness or death of our own child or the child of other parents because we refused to take advantage of available, proven, very low risk preventive measures?  As noted in the New York Times on Sunday, February 1, 2015, “Measles can kill. Before vaccines for it became widespread in 1963, millions of Americans were infected annually and 400 to 500 died each year."

While the motives of those parents refusing to allow their children an MMR vaccine are no doubt based on their belief that their actions are the right thing to do, the greater good of the community demands that we take action to prevent any further spread of the measles in Marin County. Children (especially those less than 12-15 months old) and others in our community with compromised immune systems are at highest risk. Therefore, when so directed by the Marin County Public Health Officer, if your child is unvaccinated or cannot provide laboratory confirmation of immunity and there is a case of measles in their school, they will be excluded from attending school for 21 days to protect themselves and to limit further spread of the disease.

I want to be clear that I fully support the direction of our Public Health Officer. I also urge parents to carefully review the current research and, if your child or children are unvaccinated or under vaccinated, to take steps to protect your children immediately. You may have the right not to do so, but just as there is no right to “falsely cry fire in a crowded theater,” there is no right to endanger other peoples’ children. PLEASE GET YOUR CHILDREN VACCINATED!

Mary Jane Burke
Superintendent of Marin County Schools
Marin County Office of Education
1111 Las Gallinas Avenue
San Rafael, CA  94903
(415) 499-5801

Dear RVSD Community,

A few months ago I sent you an email highlighting the importance of vaccinations against infectious diseases which can quickly spread and present serious health risks to those who do not have them.  Since then, an outbreak of measles has occurred, with 68 confirmed cases in California alone during this new year.

Below this message you'll see an important letter from Dr. Matt Willis, Public Health Officer for Marin County.  I strongly urge you to take a few minutes to read Dr. Willis’ letter, so you will have an even better understanding of how we plan to respond should there be any confirmed cases of measles here in Marin.

I previously shared the PBS NOVA video “Vaccines-Calling the Shots,” which specifically discusses measles.  If you’ve not seen this very informative video, now would be a good time to do so.  Here is the link:  http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/body/vaccines-calling-shots.html

Our RVSD school nurse, Laurel Yrun and Director of Student Services, Teri Louer, are closely monitoring this situation and though we hope there will be no reported cases of measles in our District, please know we will act quickly and decisively if or when the situation changes.

Please let me, Laurel or Teri know if you have any questions.

Thanks,

Rick Bagley, Ed.D.
Superintendent of Schools
Ross Valley School District

Letter to Parents from Dr. Matt Willis, Public Health Officer for Marin County

Carta a los padres del Dr. Matt Willis , Oficial de Salud Pública del Condado de Marin